Cyborg M(others): Feminism and the New Reproductive Technologies

Essay by marlowUniversity, Bachelor'sF, September 2006

download word file, 12 pages 3.0

Downloaded 66 times

The technological regulation of bodies and the control of reproduction are central issues within the sociology of the body. The existence of such technologies has changed and transformed the way we understand the physical body, and has in turn created spaces where new truths about the body have arisen. As such, the issues raised by reproductive technologies are central to any consideration of the sociology of the body. However, it is not the existence of the technologies themselves that determines their impact on people's lives, but the social and political context within which they are located and from which they derive their meaning. Instead of viewing ARTs statically as an essential object, they need to be understood as shifting historical practices. Like all practices, disciplines and codes, have a materiality only within the context with individual and groups' uses, appropriations and contestations. Women cannot help being shaped and transformed in their participation in these technologies; and these technologies cannot but be shaped and transformed by woman's participation.

Rejecting any fixed characterisation of these technologies then, a more useful appraisal would focus on the historical specifity of the diversity of their uses and the shifting of the meanings they generate for and by different constituencies.

In this vein a number of people have commented that we are now living in a "cyborg society", all of us to some degree cyborgian whether we accept the designation or not (Haraway, 1985; Gray, 1995; Balsamo, 1999). While the cyborg metaphor is invaluable in offering a new way of conceptualising the relationship between human beings and machines that challenges the limitations of essentialism and fixity, the idea that we are all cyborgs poses some limitations of analysis. Such a blanket conceptualisation ignores the fact that there are many ways in which women can and do...